How to Deal With High School and College Students Who Argue About Everything

Author Jonathan David · Lesson 1 for Teachers and Professors · Watch on YouTube

When a Student Disagreement Goes in Circles

A student challenges a grade, an assignment instruction, or a course rule. You explain your reasoning, and a few minutes later you’re having the same exchange all over again. In this introductory podcast for high school teachers and college instructors, I talk about how to recognize that point and end the exchange calmly.

A student may have spotted an unclear instruction or a mistake worth correcting. Ask them to point to the specific issue. If you’re both repeating the same points, pause the conversation and give the student a clear way to follow up.

How to Set a Boundary and Leave Room for Follow-Up

  1. Ask what’s in dispute. Have the student point to the feedback, instruction, or rule they want to discuss.
  2. Look at the same document. For a grading question, use the rubric. For a question about permitted help or outside sources, use the syllabus and the assignment instructions.
  3. Pause when the exchange starts repeating. If the conversation is holding up class, arrange a time to revisit the specific question after class or during office hours.

One way to say it. “Let’s pause here so we can get back to class. Bring the part of the instructions you’re questioning, and we’ll look at it together after class.”

Find more podcasts and college advice from Author Jonathan David at MathMonthly.com.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x