Author Jonathan David · Math Monthly · Watch on YouTube
What Happened in the Jordan Form Calculation
In this video, I revisit a matrix exponential problem from the Math Monthly Research Program. I asked ChatGPT to mimic a Maple calculation, and it returned a change-of-basis matrix labeled $P$. Under the convention used in our write-up, that matrix was $P^{-1}$. When I asked for the Jordan form directly using our convention, it put the two matrices in the correct order.
We also caught a separate typo in our work. The $-1$ in the inverse belongs in the upper-right entry. Writing out both matrices made it easier to see where that entry went and which matrix belonged on each side of the exponential.
How We Checked the Order of the Matrices
The write-up uses $J=PAP^{-1}$. With that convention, the matrices are
Multiplying $PAP^{-1}$ gives $J=\operatorname{diag}(1,2)$. Swapping the two factors gives a matrix with an upper-right entry of $2$, so the product fails the diagonal check.
Once we have verified $J=PAP^{-1}$, we can write $A=P^{-1}JP$ and carry that same order into the exponential.
The label $P$ depends on how you write the similarity relation. If you start with $A=PJP^{-1}$, the labels on the two change-of-basis matrices reverse. Check the defining product before carrying either matrix into the next step.
Math Monthly Research Program
This problem is part of the November work for Volume 1. Join Author Jonathan David as we work through problems in math and physics and document how we check our results. Visit MathMonthly.com.