Why Your Assigned Textbook Matters – Stewart vs. Thomas Calculus | Math Monthly LIVE

Author Jonathan David · Math Monthly Journal · Livestream Replay · Watch on YouTube

Read the Definitions Before You Start Calculating

Stewart and Thomas both teach calculus, but they organize and present the material in their own ways. In this livestream, I explain why I start with the assigned textbook when writing a solution. I compare following its notation and presentation to following an assigned writing format such as MLA or APA.

Before using an equation, check what its symbols mean and which conditions the theorem requires. Then write enough explanation for a reader to follow why it applies to your problem.

A Change-of-Basis Example From Math Monthly

I revisit a matrix exponential calculation where two sources used opposite conventions for the change-of-basis matrix. The matrix labeled $P$ in one convention played the role of $P^{-1}$ in the other. Writing the defining equation first let us check which matrix belonged on each side.

$$J=PAP^{-1} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad A=P^{-1}JP \quad\Longrightarrow\quad e^{At}=P^{-1}e^{Jt}P.$$

That check connects the notation to the calculation. Multiplying the factors gives us a way to verify that we’re using the convention consistently.

Write a Solution Someone Else Can Follow

  • Define your quantities. Introduce the variables, vectors, or matrices before using them.
  • Identify the result you’re applying. State the relevant theorem or definition and check its conditions.
  • Verify the answer. Substitute it back into the original equation or use another appropriate check.

The livestream also includes a look at how I organize these written derivations and their accompanying videos in the Math Monthly lesson library.

Get full access and perks when you become a member @MathMonthly.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x